What If … the U.S. Wasn’t Robbed within the 2002 World Cup?

America males’s nationwide group might have made the 2002 FIFA World Cup ultimate — in actual fact, they ought to have.

And but, they didn’t. Why? An apparent handball that wasn’t referred to as within the quarterfinal towards Germany. The remainder is historical past.

However WHAT IF we might rewrite historical past?

After being eradicated within the Spherical of 16 in 1994 and never making it out of the group stage in 1998, the U.S. was primed for a run in 2002. They had been capable of end as runners-up of their group, most notably defeating Portugal 3-2 and drawing with group winner South Korea. Within the Spherical of 16, they confronted Mexico for the primary time at a World Cup — and recorded a 2-0 victory behind targets from Brian McBride and Landon Donovan.

Subsequent, it was on to the quarterfinal towards powerhouse Germany. Michael Ballack received the Germans out to an early 1-0 lead within the thirty ninth minute, however the People responded with a number of attacking performs to start out the second half.

However within the fiftieth minute, every little thing modified.

_____

Off a U.S. nook kick by Donovan, a German participant tried to move the ball away from purpose— solely to have it discover a wide-open Gregg Berhalter, who took a shot at purpose from just some yards out. German keeper Oliver Kahn was capable of barely save the shot, however the ball would bounce off the arm of midfielder Torsten Frings who was defending the put up. Instantly, U.S. gamers started clamoring for a handball, and when the replay was proven —  it was clear as day.

Nevertheless, referee Hugh Dallas did not name it. And with VAR not but in existence, the decision was irreversible. Had it been referred to as, the U.S. would have been awarded a penalty kick, and Frings would have been given a purple card. As talked about, the U.S. had been dominating the primary 10 minutes of the half, and absolutely would have taken benefit of the 10-man German aspect.

However WHAT IF the handball was referred to as?

Would the U.S. have lifted its first-ever World Cup trophy? Would soccer in america be considered in a unique mild in the present day?

Let’s dive in.

_____

If the handball had been referred to as, the best-case state of affairs would have resulted in Claudio Reyna scoring the game-tying penalty— and Germany would have needed to fend off a momentum-driven American assault with simply 10 males. So lots of the legendary People might have subsequently scored the game-winning purpose— with Donovan, McBride, Reyna, Cobi Jones, Eddie Pope, and a number of other others headlining the squad. Had they superior, they might have confronted South Korea within the semifinal, whom that they had drawn with within the group stage. A win towards the co-hosts would pit the U.S. towards Brazil, and the U.S. would have made its first males’s World Cup ultimate ever. Whereas the Brazilian squad was full of superstars like Ronaldo, Ronaldinho and Rivaldo— the publicity from such a large stage might have modified the panorama of American soccer for the subsequent 20 years— whatever the end result. 

_____

Few can neglect the dominant vogue wherein the USWNT received the World Cup in 1991 and 1999. This type of success undoubtedly influenced younger American ladies watching the event, resulting in the likes of Carli Lloyd, Alex Morgan, Abby Wambach— and present stars like Sophia Wilson, Trinity Rodman, and Naomi Girma. Such an emphasis on ladies’s soccer in america has led to them successful 4 of the 9 World Cups ever held. So what would a win over Germany in 2002 have resulted in for the lads? 

Simply think about all of the younger boys who would have participated in soccer through the early 2000s as a substitute of the same old suspects— Pop Warner soccer, little league baseball, and AAU (Novice Athletic Union) basketball. For perspective, in a examine achieved by the Nationwide Federation of State Excessive Faculties in 2022, there have been 374,773 contributors in ladies soccer for that faculty 12 months— the third-highest of all sports activities. On the boy’s aspect? Soccer contributors ranked fifth, behind soccer, monitor & subject, basketball, and baseball.    

_____          

No U.S. coach has coached or received extra matches within the group’s historical past than Bruce Enviornment, with 148 and 81 respectively. He was inducted into the Nationwide Soccer Corridor of Fame in 2010, however what would his profession have seemed like if he had taken down Germany in that 2002 World Cup quarterfinal? Enviornment had already received two MLS titles with D.C. United in 1996 and 1997 earlier than spearheading the 2002 nationwide group previous the Spherical of 16 for the primary time ever. Contemplating that two Enviornment’s successors – Bob Bradley and Gregg Berhalter – had been capable of coach overseas, it isn’t unreasonable to assume he might have achieved in order effectively.

Had he taken a possible supply in Europe, that might have additionally modified the group’s fortunes on the 2006 World Cup. The U.S. didn’t make it out of the group stage in 2006, ending final of their group and in the end resulting in Enviornment’s exit three weeks after the event. He’d go on to win three extra MLS titles with the Galaxy in 2011, 2012 and 2014 and was once more employed by the nationwide group in 2016. In his second stint, the U.S. did not qualify for the 2018 World Cup— the primary time that had occurred since 1986. One can not help however surprise how all of this might have modified if the handball was referred to as in 2002.  

_____

It is unbelievable to consider how a win over Germany would have modified the panorama of the MLS and American youth academies. Such an upset might have sparked huge nationwide curiosity in soccer, resulting in unprecedented funding within the U.S. youth soccer system. With never-before-seen stress from each public and company entities, we might have seen high-level sponsorship within the MLS and a whole overhaul of youth academies— which has typically been faulted for its pay-to-play mannequin. 

The subsequent 5 to 10 years might have allowed for a community of expertise aggregation modeled after the European youth system, emphasizing technical improvement and scouting in underserved communities. In flip, it is potential that a whole technology of world-class gamers would have emerged— with gamers like Christian Pulisic showing in a lot larger numbers. Simply think about what the 2014, 2018, and 2022 World Cup outcomes would have seemed like for the U.S. had this occurred after 2002. It’s very within the realm of prospects that the U.S. could be a constant soccer powerhouse had this basis been set.  

_____

Presumably the most important query of all that arises from this hypothetical train, is simply how a lot larger soccer could be on this nation had the U.S. taken down Germany with the proper name. It is laborious to think about that Landon Donovan would not have develop into much more of an icon than he already is, and that he would have impressed a number of folks to develop into followers of the game. Whereas it is laborious to say that this single end result would have propelled soccer as the highest sport amongst People, there’s little doubt that the tens of millions of potential viewers a ultimate or semifinal match would have generated would have modified the trajectory of the game. For perspective, 26.7 million folks watched the USWNT take down Japan within the 2015 World Cup ultimate. The 2022 males’s ultimate between France and Argentina had over 25 million viewers. Simply think about a world wherein the four-and five-star highschool basketball and soccer recruits that faculties battle over grew up taking part in soccer as a substitute. We’ll by no means know.

Extra Sports activities Historical past “WHAT IFs?”:

• What if … Patriots QB Drew Bledsoe by no means received injured in 2001?
• What if … the 49ers drafted Aaron Rodgers as a substitute of Alex Smith within the 2005 NFL Draft?

Need nice tales delivered proper to your inbox? Create or log in to your FOX Sports activities account and observe leagues, groups and gamers to obtain a personalised publication day by day!

---

---